supportBest Alternatives to Tebex in 2025
Best Alternatives to Tebex in 2025
Choosing the right platform directly impacts revenue and player experience. Tebex dominates the gaming server store market (Minecraft, FiveM, Rust, Discord bots, game servers), but its 5% platform fee, VAT applied at checkout, limited customization options, and often slow support can make growth frustrating—especially when you need quick fixes or feature requests.
After testing dozens of platforms, we found competitive alternatives that offer more control, better customization, flexible payments, and responsive support—often with lower total costs and fewer limitations.
Below are the strongest alternatives we recommend and when to pick each, so you spend less time wrestling with tooling and more time selling.
How We Choose the Best Alternatives
After testing dozens of platforms, we evaluated each alternative across eight key areas that directly impact your success:
- The Pricing – Platform fees, transaction costs, and hidden charges that eat into revenue. We prioritize transparent pricing with no surprise fees.
- The Customizability – How much control you have over storefront design, checkout flow, and branding. More customization means better conversion optimization.
- The Support – Response times, quality of help, and community resources when you hit roadblocks. Good support prevents costly downtime.
- The Feature Depth – Essential features like subscriptions, gift cards, fraud prevention, and integrations that scale with your growth.
- How Easy Is It to Get Started – Setup complexity, documentation quality, and time-to-first-sale. Faster onboarding means quicker revenue.
- Game Store Integrations – How many gaming platforms and server types each solution supports (Minecraft, FiveM, Rust, Discord bots, etc.).
- Template Options – Quality and variety of pre-built storefront designs, themes, and customization tools available.
- Taxes – How platforms handle VAT/GST compliance, invoicing, and tax reporting. Proper tax handling prevents legal headaches and surprises.
These criteria ensure we recommend platforms that work for real server owners, not just impressive feature lists.
TLDR: Platform Overview
| Platform | Best For | Starting Price | Fees | Standout | Tradeoff |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tebex | Established servers with budget | $0 | 5% | Largest ecosystem & payment gateways, templates | High fees, slow support |
| CraftingStore | Multi-game server support | $0 | No platform fees | Fast setup, 8+ game integrations | Requires manual gateway setup |
| PayNow.gg | Global payments, modern checkout | $0 | 2.5%-3.5% | 75+ payment methods, MoR | Limited games, small templates collection |
| MineStoreCMS | Self-hosted control, customization | $74.99 one-time | No platform fees | Full control, no ongoing fees | Requires hosting, technical setup, manual gateway setup, limited to minecraft |
1. CraftingStore: Multi-Game Support Without Platform Fees
CraftingStore stands out for its broad game support and zero platform fees. Unlike Tebex's 5% fee, CraftingStore lets you keep 100% of your revenue after payment processor fees. The platform supports Minecraft, Hurtworld, Rust, CS:GO, Garry's Mod, Team Fortress 2, Unturned, and 7 Days to Die—making it the most versatile alternative for multi-game server owners.
What Makes It Work
- Zero platform fees – Keep 100% of revenue after payment processor fees
- 8+ game support – Minecraft, Rust, CS:GO, Garry's Mod, and more
- Fast setup – Excellent documentation and quick onboarding
- Fast support – Responsive help when you need it
- Full customization – HTML/CSS editor with Twig templates
- Essential features – Coupons, gift cards, categories, subscriptions
Setup is straightforward with excellent documentation and fast support response times. While you'll need to configure payment gateways manually (similar to MineStoreCMS), this gives you complete control over your payment processing and avoids platform fees entirely.
Best for: Multi-game server owners who want broad platform support without ongoing platform fees, and teams comfortable with manual payment gateway setup.
2. PayNow.gg: Global Payments with Merchant of Record
PayNow.gg excels at global payment coverage with 75+ payment methods and full Merchant of Record (MoR) handling. Unlike CraftingStore or MineStoreCMS where you manage taxes and compliance yourself, PayNow.gg handles VAT/GST, invoicing, and tax reporting automatically. This makes it ideal for servers targeting international audiences who need seamless local payment methods.
What Makes It Work
- 75+ payment methods – Global coverage with local payment options
- Merchant of Record – Automatic tax compliance and invoicing
- Advanced APIs – Headless integration for custom workflows
- Full chargeback protection – Disputes handled automatically
- Platform-native subscriptions – Built-in recurring payment management
- Fast support – Quick response times
The platform offers advanced headless APIs for custom integrations, platform-native subscriptions, and full chargeback protection. However, it's currently limited to 4 games and has a smaller template collection compared to Tebex or CraftingStore. The 3.5% fee is lower than Tebex's 5% + VAT, but higher than the zero platform fees offered by CraftingStore and MineStoreCMS.
Best for: Teams prioritizing global payment coverage, tax compliance automation, and modern checkout optimization, especially for international audiences.
3. MineStoreCMS: Self-Hosted Control with Maximum Flexibility
MineStoreCMS offers the ultimate in control with a one-time $74.99 purchase and zero ongoing platform fees. As a self-hosted solution, you maintain complete ownership of your data, hosting, and customization. The platform provides excellent storefront control with customizable templates and supports 24+ native payment methods, with the option to integrate PayNow Checkout for expanded payment coverage and MoR handling.
What Makes It Work
- One-time cost – $74.99 purchase, no ongoing platform fees
- Full control – Self-hosted with complete data ownership
- 24+ payment methods – Native support with PayNow integration option
- Advanced features – Fraud prevention, subscriptions, Discord integration
- Excellent customization – Complete template and styling control
- Fast support – Responsive help and documentation
The platform includes advanced features like fraud prevention, subscriptions via PayPal/Stripe/GoPay, and comprehensive operational tools including categories, gift cards, and Discord integration. However, it requires technical setup, hosting management, and manual payment gateway configuration. Currently limited to Minecraft servers, it's ideal for teams who prioritize data ownership and want to avoid ongoing platform fees.
Best for: Minecraft server owners who want maximum control, data ownership, and are comfortable with technical setup and hosting management.
Features Comparison
| Capability | Tebex | CraftingStore | PayNow.gg | MineStoreCMS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Setup speed | Good | Excellent | Excellent | Good (self‑hosted) |
| Support speed | Slow | Fast | Fast | Fast |
| Payment coverage | Strong | Good | Excellent (75+ methods) | Good (24+; 75+ via PayNow) |
| Storefront control | Good | Good | Good | Excellent |
| Template ecosystem | Strong | Good | Neutral | Neutral |
| Fees transparency | Good | Good | Good | Excellent (no platform fee) |
| Integrations / webhooks | Good | Good | Good | Good |
| Global readiness | Strong | Good | Excellent | Good (Excellent via PayNow) |
| Support speed | Slow | Fast | Fast | Fast |
| Merchant of Record | MoR | Not MoR (self‑managed gateways/taxes) | MoR | Not MoR; integrates PayNow MoR |
| Chargeback protection | Limited/varies | Gateway‑dependent | Full coverage | Gateway‑dependent; Full via PayNow |
| Headless API | Good | Webhooks; theme editor | Advanced headless APIs | Theme/integrations; headless via PayNow |
| Subscriptions | Yes | Yes (tiers) | Yes (platform‑native) | Yes (PayPal/Stripe/GoPay) |
| Hosted webstore | Yes | Yes | Yes (global edge) | Self‑hosted |
| Tax compliance handling | MoR‑handled | Merchant‑handled | MoR‑handled | Merchant‑handled; MoR via PayNow |
Notes: Labels are directional, not absolute. Your best choice depends on payment needs, audience, and workflow.
FAQ
Is switching from Tebex hard?
Not if you plan it. Migrate products in phases, keep URLs stable where possible, and validate payments and emails in a staging flow before going live.
Which alternative should I pick?
- Choose CraftingStore if you want multi-game support without platform fees and don't mind manual gateway setup.
- Choose PayNow.gg if you need global payment coverage, automatic tax compliance, and MoR handling.
- Choose MineStoreCMS if you want maximum control, data ownership, and are comfortable with technical setup.
Can I keep my current templates?
Yes. Many Qseek templates support both Tebex and CraftingStore. MineStoreCMS uses customizable templates, while PayNow.gg has a smaller template collection. Where noted, we provide platform-compatible variants; otherwise, templates are Tebex‑first. Browse template categories.
What metrics matter most after switching?
Checkout completion rate, average order value, chargeback rate, and time‑to‑cash. Improving any one of these can justify the switch.
